top of page
Search

Avalanche Of Tasting Notes

Lots of tasting to report on today. My report on Schloss Lieser is up and running on World Of Fine Wines, with part-2 appearing today, they tell me. And here’s my notes on Weingut Künstler, and the sometimes remarkable surprises I encountered.


Lieser sent me 24 wines, and Künstler 18. To taste that many wines takes a good week if I do it right, by which I mean, give the wines time, taste them repeatedly, and approach my first impressions agnostically.



A decent professional taster learns that proceeding on her first impressions is sustainably accurate within the self-contained universe of first-impression, which is a language of its own. It’s not a dialect, not a syntax; it’s an actual language that doesn’t have words for the impressions one can only form through deliberation. It’s what we mean when we say “professional,” and it’s valid in its own context. I did it for 35 years. It was inimical to my temperament but I adapted as a matter of necessity.


I don’t actually change my mind very often when I re-taste a wine open for 4-5 days. I’m actually only altering a judgment maybe 5% of the time. I see my first note as a hypothesis, and I look to subsequent tastings to affirm it, to modify it, to deepen it, and sometimes to challenge it and change it. I share that process with you if I find it illuminating, but it isn’t always.


Until I started doing this for the website, my readers had almost never read a negative note from me, though I wrote lots of them. As a merchant my task was to cull the duds and offer you the best stuff, so all those notes were praises. In my books I wrote about important and beautiful wines. And I brought that assumption to the task at hand, thinking I’d only report on the wines I liked. But eventually I concluded that doing so was actually not very interesting, and was disrespectful to the producers. They get a lot of smoke blown at them, a lot of “brilliant, chef!” stuff, and if I may say so, I think they might prefer a humane, discerning and reasonable approach that may not be relentlessly positive. It seems like a prerequisite for genuine collegiality.


That said, before I run a negative note I spend quite a bit of time trying to talk myself out of it. I’m so touched at how sweetly they sent samples to me. But if I pull punches I’m useless to them, to you, and finally to myself.

156 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page